Ok, big decision… butler’s pantry or no butler’s pantry?

A board for members to Discuss, Ask for Advice & Inspire - All things Construction & Design. Please all share the love of our homes with each other.

Post by Guest »

I’m seeing a lot of beautiful kitchens without, but they have loads of cupboards and drawers and bench space. So while my heart says yes, my head is wondering whether just a bigger kitchen will suffice. And how does it compare cost-wise.

Post by Rene'e »

They are stunning aren't they!? But we went with no butlers pantry because of cost and because cleaning one kitchen space is enough (for me haha)

Post by Meghan »

I went for walk in pantry. It could be a butlers pantry with size but didn't want any sink in it.

Post by Jane »

Yes! As someone that doesn't like guests to see that we actually live in our house, a butler's pantry is amazing for hiding away things when people are over.

Post by Naomi »

Semi Butlers here and we absolutely love it 🫶 would highly recommend…
Similar to a butlers - everything is out of sight from my kitchen but no sink/oven as we didn’t need two.

Post by Monique »

I’m building and I have a huge pantry- fully shelved. I’m not doing a butler’s because I want to stock pile canned tomatoes

Post by Kylie »

Walk in pantry would be my choice. It does depend on how big your kitchen is and how you use the space.

Post by Samantha »

Love mine. It has shelves, cupboards, drawers, microwave, second sink and dishwasher behind a barn door.

Post by Angela »

Absolutely butlers pantry!!! Hands down one of the best decisions we made when we built. Couldn’t be without it.

Post by Joy »

If you can afford one why not but only if you can include a sink, prep areas and appliance centre otherwise it’s just a storage cupboard

Post by Karen »

I had the house of my dreams and have built so I can have a butlers. I’ll have main sink in it and a dishwasher. We will do the everyday things in Buttler allowing main kitchen to be flitter free.

If I want to make a cuppa and a sandwich I’ll make it in there so I don’t have to care if I leave something out.

Post by Mary »

Instead of a butler pantry I had the entire room as just a pantry - no sink no appliances- best thing.Have the pots pans- all kitchen small electrical goods on the shelves easy to take out and put back and unpacking grocery bags - Easy as - all done in the one area

Post by Joanne »

I like my butlers pantry but have to say I miss my 2 big open doors to my old pantry as I could see everything in front of me instead of always bending down under the bench to look for things

Post by Dimity »

I don’t see the point in the whole sink thing but I just went a walk in with storage and a place for appliances.

For me, I have no interest in cooking and prepping in a cupboard and I stack the dishwasher as I cook and after meals.

Post by Juli »

I am in the midst of converting an excess room into a dry pantry directly off the kitchen and accessed via the original double pantry doors... all the advice I got from professionals in my area is that this will put me at the top of desirability in terms of offering, which certainly helped convince the Mr to get on board... but is something I have wanted for myself ever since we bought this house over a decade ago (good things take time, lol)

My capital improvement value is around $15k with the addition... costing me about $2.5k

These room.are what people want now, so if you have the option for it, my advice is to go for it!

Last bumped by Anonymous on Sat Feb 04, 2023 1:52 pm.
Post Reply
  • Similar Topics
    Last post